← Back to Lido
Lido · closed proposal

Adopt the CMv2 Penalty Framework

0xFf64…1fCe·ended 4d ago·Discussion ↗·MEDIUM RISK
🐳 Whale activity
Voters
55
LDO voted
58.01M
≈$21.85M
Token price
$0.38

AI summary

This proposal introduces a new penalty framework for Lido's Curated Module v2 (CMv2). It outlines how the Curated Module Committee (CMC) will assess and apply penalties to Node Operators for incidents like misconfigurations, underperformance, or other protocol-impacting events. The framework emphasizes a case-by-case evaluation based on factors like impact, cause, and preventability, rather than automatic penalties. It also grants the CMC authority to update operational elements of the framework without requiring a separate DAO vote for each change, as long as core principles remain intact.

Impact

If passed, this proposal will establish a standardized process for penalizing Node Operators within Lido's CMv2, aiming to compensate the protocol for losses, discourage risky behavior, and protect stakers. Node Operators will face clearer guidelines and consequences for operational failures, while the CMC gains more autonomy in managing the framework's operational details. The direct financial impact on the treasury cannot be determined from this proposal alone, as it sets up a framework for penalties rather than enacting specific ones.

Read full proposal on Snapshot

Voting results

For58.01M (100.0%)
Against0 (0.0%)
58.01M LDO · ≈$21.85M · 55 votersblock 25502408

Votes over time

x-axis = % of voting window elapsed · y-axis = cumulative VP per choice

🐳 Whale votes

12 votes > 5% VP
0x42e6…3fb0
10d ago · voted For
58.2%
7.41M VP
≈$2.79M
0x6cd6…b52e
7d ago · voted For
13.9%
7.15M VP
≈$2.69M
0xb664…f890
7d ago · voted For
10.8%
6.25M VP
≈$2.35M
0xa418…b737
10d ago · voted For
32.2%
6.05M VP
≈$2.28M
0x8172…922e
8d ago · voted For
10.4%
5.36M VP
≈$2.02M
0x1f76…5ed6
11d ago · voted For
100.0%
5.31M VP
≈$2.00M
0x4af8…6a0b
10d ago · voted For
22.0%
5.30M VP
≈$1.99M
0x55bc…f0fa
8d ago · voted For
6.8%
3.48M VP
≈$1.31M
0x3133…5c00
9d ago · voted For
9.8%
3.05M VP
≈$1.15M
0x45bc…fd99
9d ago · voted For
7.3%
2.04M VP
≈$769.0K
0x6f9b…8a1d
10d ago · voted For
6.2%
1.59M VP
≈$597.5K
0xf1cc…ac93
11d ago · voted For
81.5%
499 VP
≈$188

Full proposal

Original markdown · Lido

Summary

This proposal introduces the Penalty Framework for the Curated Module v2 (CMv2) as the baseline process for assessing and applying penalties to Node Operators. The Framework establishes how the Curated Module Committee (CMC), with analysis and support from the NOM team (Node Operator Mechanisms workstream of DAO contributors), reviews incidents involving Node Operator conduct, misconfiguration, underperformance, or other protocol-impacting events…

📚 Similar past proposals

Finding similar proposals…